Jump to section (23)
Collaboration grows the pool; competition splits it. Organizations serving the same community can share research, coordinate campaign timing, and co-fund donor education without merging brands. The practical starting point is a joint calendar so appeals do not land on the same donor in the same week from four different charities.
Key Takeaways
- 1Muslim nonprofits are held back by scarcity mindset, competition culture, and a talent gap, not by lack of funding.
- 2The three levers of scalability are People, Process, and Tools, each requiring deliberate investment.
- 3A trillion-dollar Muslim wealth transfer is underway, and organizations that professionalize will capture it.
- 4Speaking the language of funder priorities (outcomes over activities, data-backed proposals) unlocks institutional funding.
- 5Performance culture paired with growth investment retains talent and drives mission impact.
The constraints holding Muslim nonprofits back are rarely financial. Culture, mindset, and talent development account for more of the performance gap than funding does.
In Episode 22 of The Muslim Nonprofit Show, host Tayyab Yunus sits down with Sarah Ali, founder of the Muslim Philanthropy Network and SA Philanthropy. They discuss the changes the sector needs to thrive. Sarah shares her 14-year career, from global roles at Doctors Without Borders and Amnesty International to her current work developing professional practice in Muslim philanthropy.
From Law School to Global Nonprofit Leadership
Put collaboration into practice
Select a step to trace the sequence
Use this diagram with the Islamic Giving Campaign Playbook (toolkit).
Sarah's path into philanthropy was not linear. She pivoted from law school into fundraising through face-to-face donor acquisition, connecting people to the joy of giving. This early experience framed a 14-year career at international nongovernmental organizations like Doctors Without Borders and Amnesty International.
At these organizations, she learned how large-scale systems work and how to grow fundraising revenue. However, the systems supporting mainstream global organizations often failed to reach Muslim nonprofits. Many relied on passion and volunteers alone, without established training and career development for staff.
That gap led Sarah to found SA Philanthropy, a full-service fundraising agency, and the Muslim Philanthropy Network, a capacity-building organization dedicated to professionalizing the sector.
What's Missing in Muslim Nonprofits Today
Though the Muslim nonprofit sector has grown significantly in reach and visibility, Sarah identifies three core challenges that create fragility:
1. A Scarcity Mindset
Many organizations assume there is not enough money or talent to go around. They become defensive, withholding information and treating peers as competitors for limited resources. Start by identifying one training need you could address with a peer organization.
A scarcity mindset can discourage useful collaboration. Before assuming resources are unavailable, identify shared training needs, complementary programmes, and potential joint funding opportunities.
2. A Culture of Competition Over Collaboration
When organizations view each other as rivals, donors face overlapping appeals, talent is poached rather than developed, and teams work in isolation. Sharing learning or planning campaigns together can help organizations reach more supporters. We recommend agreeing what information can be shared before starting joint work.
3. A Talent and Professionalization Gap
The sector struggles to retain professional talent. While compensation is a factor, culture is often the primary driver of turnover. Without clear career pathways, talented practitioners hit a ceiling within two to three years and leave for mainstream organizations. The sector loses its best people because it has not built the systems to keep them.
The Three Levers of Scalability
Three levers of scalability
Select a component to focus on it
Use this diagram with the Islamic Giving Campaign Playbook (toolkit).
Sarah introduces a framework for sustainable scaling based on three levers: People, Process, and Tools.
People
Your team is your primary asset, but hiring is only the first step. You must invest in onboarding, training, and mentorship. This means moving beyond the "family culture" common in Muslim organizations.
While family culture sounds warm, it often leads to unclear boundaries and a lack of accountability. A professional culture provides clear expectations and honest feedback as a form of genuine investment.
Specific actions:
Process
Systems beat heroics. If your organization relies on one or two key people to function, you have a bottleneck, not a resilient institution. Applying these principles across your fundraising storytelling and donor journey channels ensures creative outputs reach donors on schedule.
Documenting processes ensures knowledge remains even if a team member leaves. Key processes to document include:
Tools
Technology can save staff time. Many Muslim nonprofits still rely on manual processes and spreadsheets. A CRM, a system for tracking donor relationships, and project management software can help organize the work. Start by identifying the recurring task that takes the most staff time before choosing software.
Sarah recommends:
The Trillion-Dollar Muslim Wealth Transfer
Plan for generational change by asking supporters about their long-term intentions and preferred ways to contribute. Do not infer a donor's wealth or legacy plans from their background.
Younger and older supporters may have different communication preferences. Ask what each donor values, and explore relevant Islamic finance and Waqf structures without assuming a particular transfer of assets.
The organizations that capture this transfer will be those that speak the language of professional philanthropy while honoring Islamic traditions like Zakat and Sadaqah. Organizations relying solely on Friday appeals and Ramadan guilt trips risk missing this generational opportunity.
Speaking the Language of Funder Priorities
A critical skill for Muslim nonprofits is the ability to translate their work for institutional donors. This is about framing impact in ways that resonate with foundation officers and government managers.
How to Translate Your Impact
Building a Performance Culture
Embracing a performance culture does not mean becoming "corporate" at the expense of values. It is about creating psychological safety and authentic leadership that allows staff to excel.
What Performance Culture Looks Like in Practice
The Future of Muslim Philanthropy
Sarah envisions a sector where organizations collaborate on shared challenges and talent is celebrated. In this future, systems help organizations grow without burnout. Organizations such as the Muslim Philanthropy Network and SA Philanthropy work on building this professional infrastructure.
What You Can Do Today
About the Podcast
The Muslim Nonprofit Show is hosted by Dr. Tayyab Yunus and features conversations with leaders on building effective, values-driven organizations. Subscribe on YouTube.
Put this into practice
Choose these tasks as a starting assignment for your team. The roles and review timing below are suggested working arrangements, not benchmarks.
1. Define one shared problem
Suggested owner: Executive director. Invite a peer charity to discuss overlapping campaign timing, donor education or staff learning. Draft a one-page note naming the shared purpose and each organisation's contribution without sharing identifiable donor records.
2. Document one recurring handoff
Suggested owner: Operations lead. Choose donor acknowledgement or campaign approval and write the steps, owners and escalation route. Ask the staff using it to test whether another colleague could complete the task from the checklist.
3. Agree a small joint assignment
Suggested owner: Partnership lead. Choose one feasible activity and record responsibilities, approvals and a review date. Keep brand ownership and the boundaries of any information sharing explicit.
Check progress: At a quarterly review, check whether the joint assignment was delivered and whether the documented process reduced unresolved handoffs. Continue, revise or pause based on what actually happened.
Your homework
Operating from a scarcity mindset encourages charities to hoard information and treat peer organisations as rivals, which fragments donor support and accelerates staff turnover. Sustainable growth requires moving beyond defensive competition and embedding reliable systems across people, processes, and technology.
Documenting core workflows and collaborating on shared initiatives enables organisations to capture expanding philanthropic wealth and translate their impact effectively to institutional funders.
Before you move on to anything else, complete these three tasks:
1. Draft a two page donor acknowledgement workflow document by Friday, setting out designated task owners, delivery deadlines, and escalation stages.
2. Draft a one page collaboration brief by next Tuesday that outlines a single joint project with a peer charity and defines explicit boundaries for data sharing.
3. Produce a written professional development plan and training budget for every staff member by next Friday to support retention and establish transparent career pathways.
Resources
Put this guide into practice
Enter your name and email to get the printable article or a matching template immediately.
Frequently Asked Questions
QWhy do Muslim nonprofits struggle to scale?
Three core challenges hold the sector back: a scarcity mindset that treats every peer organization as a competitor, a lack of documented systems and processes, and a talent gap caused by insufficient professional development and career pathways. Investing in project management is one of the fastest ways to address the process gap.
QWhat are the three levers of nonprofit scalability?
People (investing in onboarding, training, and performance culture), Process (documenting and systematizing core workflows so knowledge doesn't leave with individuals), and Tools (deploying CRM, marketing automation, and analytics platforms that enable efficiency at scale). Our guide on digital-first fundraising covers the Tools lever in depth.
QWhat is the Muslim wealth transfer opportunity?
First-generation Muslim immigrants have built substantial wealth over 30 to 40 years, as documented by the Islamic Finance Council UK. That wealth is transferring to digitally savvy second and third-generation children interested in strategic philanthropy. Combined with triple-digit growth in Islamic finance assets, this represents a trillion-dollar opportunity for organizations that can professionalize. Understanding mid-level donor strategy is key to cultivating these emerging philanthropists.
QHow can nonprofits speak the language of funders?
Lead with outcomes instead of activities, align with funder frameworks like the UN SDGs, use both quantitative and qualitative data, publish transparent financials, and invest in professional grant writing capacity. SEO thinking can help you understand and adopt the language your funders actually use.
QWhat does performance culture look like in a nonprofit?
Clear role definitions, regular feedback through weekly one-on-ones, data-informed decision-making, genuine investment in professional development, and healthy accountability where underperformance is addressed directly and compassionately. Learn how psychological safety and identity shape the conditions for a healthy performance culture.
Evidence
Every statistic and study referenced above links to its primary source. Each entry has a stable anchor, so citations stay consistent over time.
- 1The Muslim Nonprofit Show, Episode 22 · youtube.com
The Muslim Nonprofit Show, undated. Primary interview informing this article.
- 2
- 3
Related questions
About the author and our standards
Founder & CEO, SA Philanthropy
Sarah Ali is the founder and CEO of SA Philanthropy, helping mission-driven organizations raise more and scale their impact. She is also the founder of the Muslim Philanthropy Network.
This article was reviewed by the SA Philanthropy editorial team before publication. We source every statistic, name every author, date every update, and correct errors on request. Read our editorial policy.
